Silence Isn’t Inaction: Spiritual Action Beyond Words & Visibility

A woman holding her hand to her lips in the "shhh" or quiet gesture, against a pink background.

I recently came across a quote on social media that created some drama and confusion, especially among spiritual leaders, coaches, and trauma-informed practitioners. While the quote may be been intended to inspire action during crisis or injustice, many spiritual people felt personally attacked or called out. This tension raises deeper questions about the role of silence in spiritual leadership, emotional intelligence, and conscious activism. In this post we'll explore the meaning behind the quote, break down the psychology of silent action versus inaction, and uncover how spiritual responses during crisis often look very different that we expect, especially in today's visibility-driven world.

The Quote:

“Any 'spiritual teacher,' coach or therapist who has been silent during a genocide has nothing of value to teach you. Nothing.” ~ Source Unknown

When Bold Words Spark Deep Feelings

I can see how that quote might stir up a lot of emotion:

It's bold. It's blunt. And it sounds like it was written by someone carrying pain or disillusionment, perhaps someone who has seen the world through the lens of betrayal, of false promises, or of people staying comfortable while others suffer. It’s a quote based on the idea that silence in the face of oppression equals complicity; and on some level, that belief makes sense. Most of us, when we see suffering, feel a natural urge to help, to speak out, to protect others. We see injustice and want to do something. Anything.

After all, genocide doesn’t happen in a vacuum. It happens when people are dehumanized because of race, sex, religion, or ethnicity. These aren’t distant ideas, they’re painfully human. And sadly, no culture or religion is entirely free from having been both victim and perpetrator at different points in history.

But silence doesn’t always mean someone is doing nothing.

What I think truly upsets people isn’t just the silence itself, it’s the feeling that someone they admire or look to for guidance is ignoring the pain. That they’ve chosen comfort over courage. And when it comes to spiritual teachers, coaches, or therapists, people who are supposed to be tuned in to the suffering of others, that kind of silence can feel like a betrayal.

But here’s where it gets complicated: from a spiritual perspective, action doesn’t always look the way we expect it to.

A person who has devoted their life to cultivating inner peace, mindfulness, and spiritual connection may not take up a megaphone when the world erupts into violence. Instead, they might turn inward, reflecting on how to use their energy, presence, and actions to quietly serve those in need. They may work behind the scenes, away from the spotlight. They may choose stillness over noise, because they believe that lasting change begins with consciousness, not chaos.

To someone not on that path, this can appear passive – or worse, indifferent. But it’s not.

Understanding the Psychology behind Silent Action

When silence looks like inaction, it’s easy to misjudge what’s really happening beneath the surface. But psychology, neuroscience, and leadership studies offer strong evidence that quiet forms of support are just as valid, often more sustainable, than loud ones.

The Bystander Effect Isn’t the Whole Story

The famous bystander effect suggests people are less likely to intervene during crises when others are present. But this research also uncovered that many do act—just not publicly. They may help through private channels, donate quietly, or provide direct support to someone suffering without making a scene. In spiritual or therapeutic spaces, this “low-visibility help” is often the norm.

Moral Injury and Compassion Fatigue

Spiritual teachers, therapists, and even activists can experience moral injury—a form of trauma that comes from being unable to stop the suffering they witness. They may also face compassion fatigue, leading them to go silent in order to protect their emotional and mental health. This isn’t apathy—it’s endurance. Silence becomes a form of self-preservation to ensure they can continue doing the work they’ve committed their lives to.

Emotional Intelligence Leads to Non-Reactive Leadership

Those with high emotional intelligence often respond to crises through reflection rather than reaction. Rather than jumping to immediate action, they pause, assess the deeper needs, and move with intentionality. This response can feel underwhelming to the outside world—but in reality, it’s a mature and grounded form of leadership.

Quiet Leadership Is a Recognized Model

Psychology and organizational studies recognize “quiet leadership” as a highly effective style. These leaders operate through listening, empowering others, and modeling calm under pressure. They lead from behind rather than in front. It’s a subtle power, but often more lasting than flashy leadership rooted in performance.

Polyvagal Theory: Silence as Nervous System Protection

According to polyvagal theory, people respond to threat not just with fight or flight, but also by freezing or shutting down to survive. In situations of danger or overwhelm, silence may be the body’s way of regulating itself. Spiritual leaders or trauma-informed practitioners often teach from a place of nervous system awareness, and may choose calm silence over outward engagement to avoid escalating fear or harm.

Post-Traumatic Growth Often Begins in Stillness

Research into post-traumatic growth shows that deep transformation and healing often begin in periods of silence and reflection. Before we rebuild, we grieve. Before we speak, we feel. Silence is not only natural in the aftermath of trauma—it’s necessary.

Together, these principles show that silence is often a sign of intentionality, reflection, or emotional safety—not indifference. It’s not that nothing is happening. It’s that the work is happening where it can’t always be seen.

Pope Pius XII: A Case of Silent Action

Let’s take a historical example. Pope Pius XII took office in 1939, just as World War II was igniting. He’s been criticized for not speaking out more publicly against the Holocaust. To some, he seemed distant and disengaged at a time when moral leadership was desperately needed.

But history tells a more complex story.

At the time, the Vatican was bound by treaties that demanded political neutrality, agreements he inherited but also supported, in hopes of maintaining peace for Catholics worldwide. But when Hitler rose to power, those protections dissolved. Catholic churches were shuttered, clergy were arrested, and the Church itself was targeted for suppression.

Publicly denouncing the Nazis would have put millions more Catholics at risk. So, Pope Pius XII chose a different path. He focused on humanitarian aid, even though many of his efforts were blocked. He turned the Vatican into a sanctuary, helping thousands of Jews and other persecuted people escape, regardless of faith. These weren’t symbolic gestures. These were acts of real, quiet resistance that saved lives.

To the outside world, he seemed silent. To those he helped, he was a lifeline.

The Power of Unseen Labor

Not all resistance is loud or public. Not all silence is inaction. And not all inaction is apathy.

Sometimes, people act in ways we can’t see or measure. People:

donate quietly
offer spiritual support (ex. prayer)
write letters or organize discreetly
protect loved ones
hold space in private moments
preserve energy for the long fight

These things don’t show up on social media, but they matter deeply.

When we confuse visibility with virtue, we risk overlooking the quiet labor of those who are actually doing the work—just not in the way we expect.

Responding to Silence: Accountability vs. Assumption

There’s nothing wrong with wanting more from our leaders, spiritual or otherwise. Accountability is important. But we also have to stay curious, to ask how someone might be responding before assuming they aren’t. We need to remember that silence can come from fear, wisdom, limitation, or protection, and that sometimes the most powerful actions don’t come with hashtags or headlines.

As people walking a spiritual path, we’re not called to judge from a place of ego, but to discern with compassion and understanding.

A Personal Reflection on Patience and Spiritual Waiting

In my journey, I have faced many different challenges. One of the biggest has been the opening of a retail location for my business. Seems like it would be easy, right?

I live in a town that is dominated by Christianity, there are seven churches on Church Street alone, and even more churches in the surrounding area. Non-Christian organizations such as Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Pagan, and others, exist here, but they're not well represented, especially in public or civic spaces. What gets visibility is almost entirely decided by people with strong religious and political beliefs.

Despite the town's need for continued growth, there's been a noticeable decline in retail activity. Storefronts sit empty. Businesses open and close quickly. And while it may look like economics on the surface, I believe part of the problem is cultural resistance to anything outside the norm.

When I first began pursuing my storefront, I faced backlash. A former employer found out and, through conversations with his golf buddies, many of whom have influence in the local business community, he quietly created resistance behind the scenes. Doors that once seemed open started to close. Rather than push forward into conflict, I chose to wait. That decision, while it may have looked like inaction from the outside, was actually a protective and strategic pause. Now, looking back, I’m grateful I did. It gave me time to observe, plan, and stay aligned with my purpose, without compromising my vision or peace.

I see that waiting as an essential step in my journey. Patience is key when deciding where and how to build something lasting. I'm observing patterns. I'm watching other businesses struggle with their approach. I'm learning.

I can't force the town's decision-markers to change their minds. But I trust that, in time, they'll begin to see the need for something different. My silence and “inaction” have taught me patience. Behind the scenes, I've been strategizing, refining ideas, and building something stronger, so that when the right opportunity appears, I'll be ready to act.

Spiritually, I want to help the community to grow and flourish. Thought I don't identify as strictly Christian, I do believe in God. As an Omnist, I honor all paths, every God, Goddess, spirit, and sacred tradition, with equal reverence. I believe we all have something meaningful to contribute, and our beliefs can help us support one another rather than divide.

That's the heart of my business: creating a space where all beliefs are welcome. But to do that effectively, I have to start quietly. I have to build trust. Forcing change rarely works – it creates resistance, defensiveness, and fear.

So, I stay small and quiet, not because I'm afraid, but because I am listening. I'm preparing. And I am waiting for the right moment to become the kind of change my community needs.

Final Thoughts: Why Silence Can Still Be Spiritual Action

We live in a world that glorifies visibility. It is all about the likes, shares, and bold statements. But when it comes to spirituality, healing, and leadership, not all valuable action is loud or public. Sometimes, the most powerful forms of resistance, care, and change happen quietly, behind the scenes, or within a person’s heart and mind.

To assume someone’s silence means they have nothing to offer is to misunderstand how many spiritual paths actually work. Stillness is not weakness. Reflection is not avoidance. And waiting is not giving up.

True spiritual work often begins in silence. It grows in private acts of love, in energy intentionally held, and in quiet support for those who need it most. Silence can mean:

They're healing.
They're discerning.
They're protecting their nervous system.
They're planning for the right moment.

Before judging someone’s silence, ask: What kind of action am I hoping to see? And is it possible they’re already doing it, just in a way I don’t recognize?

Key Takeaways: Understanding Silence as Powerful Spiritual Action

Not all action is visible. People often help quietly through emotional support, planning, private aid, or spiritual presence.
Spiritual leaders may act from inner alignment. Silence can be a conscious choice to protect peace, maintain clarity, or prevent harm.
Scientific research supports quiet responses. Emotional intelligence, polyvagal theory, and quiet leadership all affirm that calm, internal action is powerful and effective.
Compassion fatigue and moral injury are real. Silence may be a sign of deep empathy—and the need to recover in order to keep serving.
History shows quiet action saves lives. Leaders like Pope Pius XII made silent choices that protected others and influenced change behind the scenes.
Personal waiting is not wasted time. Strategic patience, especially in spiritually grounded paths, allows space for clarity, timing, and purpose.

If you're feeling unsure about whether your silence or stillness is meaningful; trust that it can be. Your presence, your energy, and your intention may be doing more than you realize. Sometimes the most impactful work happens where no one is watching.

Athena's Attic of Secrets